Amazon vs Shopify Fees
A complete cost comparison between the world's largest marketplace and the leading direct-to-consumer platform — at every revenue level from $10K to $500K/month.
Marketplace vs Own Store: Two Different Models
Amazon and Shopify represent fundamentally different approaches to ecommerce. Amazon is a marketplace — it provides the audience, the trust, and the logistics infrastructure in exchange for a large cut of every sale. Shopify is a storefront platform — it gives you the tools to build your own branded store, but you are responsible for driving traffic.
This fundamental difference shapes every aspect of their fee structures. Amazon charges high commissions (8–15%) because it delivers customers to you. Shopify charges low transaction fees (0–2.9%) because you bring customers yourself. Understanding this trade-off is essential for choosing the right platform — or using both strategically.
In this guide, we break down every fee category, model total costs at four revenue levels, and help you decide which platform makes sense for your specific business type.
Fee Structure Comparison
Direct side-by-side comparison of every fee category between Amazon and Shopify.
| Fee Category | Amazon | Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| Commission / Referral Fee | 8–15% (most categories 15%) | 0% with Shopify Payments |
| Transaction Fee | Included in referral fee | 0–2% (3rd party gateways only) |
| Credit Card Processing | Included in referral fee | 2.4–2.9% + $0.30 |
| Monthly Subscription | $39.99/mo (Pro) or $0.99/item | $39/mo (Basic) – $399/mo (Advanced) |
| Listing Fees | None | None |
| Fulfillment (Platform) | FBA: $3.22–$6.10+/unit | Shopify Fulfillment Network or self-ship |
| Storage Fees | $0.87–$2.40/cu ft/mo | None (self-stored) or 3PL rates |
| Refund Fee | Up to $5 per refund | Processing fee not returned |
| Chargeback Fee | $20 (not always enforced) | $15 |
Total Cost Analysis at Different Revenue Levels
How fees add up at four monthly revenue tiers. Amazon assumes 15% referral fee category with FBA fulfillment. Shopify assumes Shopify Payments with self-fulfillment.
$10,000/mo Monthly Revenue
Amazon
Shopify
$50,000/mo Monthly Revenue
Amazon
Shopify
$100,000/mo Monthly Revenue
Amazon
Shopify
$500,000/mo Monthly Revenue
Amazon
Shopify
Key Insight
At $50K/month, Amazon takes $15,590 (31.2%) while Shopify takes $1,635 (3.3%). That's a $13,955/month difference — or $167,460 per year. The question is whether Amazon's built-in traffic justifies that premium, or whether you can drive equivalent traffic to your own Shopify store for less than $167K/year in marketing spend.
Fulfillment Cost Comparison
FBA vs self-fulfillment vs Shopify Fulfillment Network — the logistics costs that often make or break profitability.
| Factor | Amazon (FBA) | Shopify (Self/3PL) |
|---|---|---|
| Pick & Pack Cost | $3.22–$6.10+/unit (FBA) | $0 (self) or 3PL rates |
| Storage Cost | $0.87–$2.40/cu ft/mo | $0 (self) or 3PL rates |
| Shipping Speed | 1–2 days (Prime) | 2–7 days (varies by method) |
| Prime Badge | Yes (with FBA) | No |
| Customer Service | Handled by Amazon | Handled by seller |
| Returns Processing | Handled by Amazon | Handled by seller |
| Long-Term Storage | $6.90/cu ft after 365 days | N/A (self-managed) |
| Multi-Channel Fulfillment | MCF available ($5+/unit) | Via Shopify Fulfillment Network |
Payment Processing
Amazon
- ✓Payment processing included in referral fee — no extra charge
- ✓Supports all major credit cards, debit cards, and Amazon gift cards
- ✓Payouts every 14 days to your bank account
- ✗No choice of payment processor — Amazon handles everything
- ✗No access to customer payment data for remarketing
- ✗Settlement reports aggregate multiple transactions
Shopify Payments
- ✓2.4–2.9% + $0.30 per transaction (varies by plan)
- ✓Zero additional transaction fee when using Shopify Payments
- ✓Daily payouts available (1–3 business day settlement)
- ✓Full customer data ownership for remarketing
- ✓Per-transaction exports for easy bookkeeping
- ✗Not available in all countries
Audience Reach vs Brand Control
Amazon: Maximum Reach
Amazon has 200M+ Prime members and processes over 300 million active customer accounts. Sellers get immediate access to this audience without spending on marketing — but at the cost of high fees and limited branding.
- Pros: Built-in traffic, Prime shipping trust, established checkout
- Cons: No customer email access, commoditized listings, price pressure from competitors
- Best for: Product discovery, competitive/commodity categories, new brands needing sales velocity
Shopify: Full Brand Control
Shopify gives you a fully branded storefront with complete control over design, customer experience, and data. You own the customer relationship — but you must drive your own traffic through ads, SEO, and social media.
- Pros: Full branding, customer data ownership, email marketing, lower fees
- Cons: No built-in traffic, marketing costs can be significant, trust-building needed
- Best for: Brand builders, repeat-purchase products, DTC brands, niche markets
Accounting & Export Differences
Amazon Settlement Reports
- ●Payouts every 14 days with aggregated settlement data
- ●Fees, refunds, and adjustments mixed into a single deposit
- ●Multiple report types (Orders, Returns, Settlement, Payment)
- ●Difficult to reconcile individual transactions with bank deposits
- ✓PrimeConnect's Amazon to QuickBooks converter normalizes these reports
Shopify Transaction Exports
- ✓Per-transaction CSV exports with clear line items
- ✓Daily payouts — easier to match with bank deposits
- ✓Separate fee breakdown (processing, transaction, shipping)
- ✓Dual-format support (Payout and Transaction exports)
- ✓PrimeConnect's Shopify to QuickBooks converter handles both formats
Which Platform is Better for Your Business?
Choose Amazon If...
- • You sell commodity/competitive products
- • You want immediate access to millions of buyers
- • Your margins support 20–35% in total fees
- • You prefer hands-off fulfillment (FBA)
- • You're launching a new brand and need sales velocity
Choose Shopify If...
- • You're building a recognizable brand
- • You have (or can build) your own traffic sources
- • You want to own customer data and emails
- • You sell subscription or repeat-purchase products
- • You want maximum profit margins per sale
Use Both If...
- • You want maximum reach AND brand building
- • You can handle multi-channel inventory management
- • You want to convert Amazon customers into direct buyers
- • You sell in competitive categories but have a strong brand
- • You use PrimeConnect to unify accounting across both
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Amazon or Shopify cheaper for new sellers?
For new sellers with low volume (<$10K/month), Shopify Basic ($39/month) with Shopify Payments is typically cheaper. You pay only 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction with no additional commission, totaling roughly 3.5% in fees. Amazon's 15% referral fee alone exceeds Shopify's total fee rate. However, Amazon provides built-in traffic that Shopify does not, so you may need to invest in marketing to drive traffic to your Shopify store.
What percentage does Amazon take per sale?
Amazon takes 8–15% as a referral fee depending on the product category, with most categories at 15%. This fee includes payment processing — there is no separate credit card processing charge. On top of the referral fee, FBA sellers pay $3.22–$6.10+ per unit for fulfillment and $0.87–$2.40 per cubic foot per month for storage. Total Amazon fees typically range from 20–35% of the sale price when using FBA.
Does Shopify charge a percentage of sales?
Shopify charges 0% transaction fee when using Shopify Payments — you only pay the credit card processing rate (2.4–2.9% + $0.30 depending on your plan tier). If you use a third-party payment gateway like PayPal or Stripe directly, Shopify adds a 0.5–2% transaction fee on top of whatever the gateway charges. Using Shopify Payments eliminates this extra fee entirely.
Is Amazon FBA worth the cost compared to self-fulfillment?
FBA is worth it if: (1) you need Prime eligibility and access to Amazon's 200M+ Prime members, (2) your products are small/light (lower FBA fees), and (3) you want hands-off logistics. FBA costs $3.22–$6.10+ per unit but includes 2-day shipping, customer service, and returns processing. For sellers who already have their own traffic and fulfillment infrastructure, self-fulfillment is significantly cheaper — the savings can be reinvested in marketing.
Can I sell on both Amazon and Shopify simultaneously?
Absolutely — and many of the most successful ecommerce businesses do exactly this. Use Amazon for product discovery and high-volume sales driven by the marketplace's built-in traffic. Use Shopify to build your brand, capture email addresses, and convert repeat customers at much lower fees. PrimeConnect's free tools can convert transaction data from both platforms into QuickBooks for unified multi-channel accounting.
How do Amazon and Shopify differ for accounting and bookkeeping?
Amazon provides settlement reports every 14 days with aggregated transaction data, which makes line-item reconciliation challenging. Fees, refunds, and sales are often bundled together. Shopify provides per-transaction exports with clear fee breakdowns that are much easier to reconcile with bank deposits. PrimeConnect offers free converter tools for both platforms that normalize the data into clean, QuickBooks-ready formats with proper fee categorization.
Convert Amazon & Shopify Data to QuickBooks — Free
Whether you sell on Amazon, Shopify, or both — PrimeConnect's free converter tools normalize your transaction data into clean, QuickBooks-ready formats with proper fee categorization. 100% browser-based, nothing to install.
Browse Free Tools